MOGADISHU — Somalia’s Supreme Court has agreed to hear opposition arguments regarding the new Constitution, with a major decision expected. The development marks a significant moment in the ongoing political dispute over the 2026 constitutional amendments.
However, it remains unclear who among the opposition filed the case, and whether the opposition as a whole agrees that this is the right path forward. Some observers have raised the possibility that the case is a strategy orchestrated by Villa Somalia and that the proceedings could amount to a sham court process completely managed by the government, with the outcome determined in advance.
The Jurisdictional Question: Can the Supreme Court Hear This Case?
A central question raised by the decision is whether the Supreme Court has the constitutional mandate to hear a case concerning the constitution itself, given the absence of a functioning Constitutional Court.
Under the 2012 Provisional Constitution, the Constitutional Court was designated as the sole body with jurisdiction over constitutional interpretation. Article 109 of the 2012 Constitution established the Constitutional Court as a distinct institution, separate from the Federal Supreme Court, composed of five judges including the Chief Justice. The provisional framework stipulated that any constitutional dispute, whether arising from a pending case or referred directly, must be adjudicated by the Constitutional Court.
The 2026 Constitutional Amendments retained the Constitutional Court as a separate institution within the judicial structure. Article 129 of the amended constitution establishes the courts of the country as the Federal Supreme Court, the Constitutional Court, the High Courts of the Federal Member States and the Banadir Court, the Courts of Appeal, and the Courts of First Instance. The Constitutional Court remains a specialized institution composed of five judges.
Under the amended framework, the Federal Supreme Court functions strictly as an apex court for federal law. It does not adjudicate constitutional questions. Where a state constitution or state law is alleged to violate the Federal Constitution, the dispute is referred to the Constitutional Court, which exercises constitutional review. This separation, according to legal analyses of the amendments, is designed to preserve constitutional supremacy while keeping ordinary federal adjudication distinct from constitutional litigation.
The critical problem is that the Constitutional Court has never been established. As legal analyses have noted, the 2012 Constitution mandated its creation, but it was never formed due to political, legal and financial obstacles. The 2026 amendments retained the institution on paper but did not resolve the practical question of how constitutional review would function in its absence.
This gap has created a constitutional vacuum. If the Constitutional Court is the only body with jurisdiction over constitutional interpretation, and it does not exist, then no court has a clear mandate to rule on the constitutionality of the amended constitution. The Supreme Court’s decision to accept the case could be interpreted as an attempt to fill that vacuum, but it could equally be seen as an overreach beyond its constitutional mandate.
The October 14 Deadline: Ministers Forced to Choose
The constitutional dispute has taken on new urgency as a critical deadline approaches. The Independent Constitutional Review and Implementation Commission (ICRIC) has set October 14, 2026, as the date when provisions barring officials from holding dual roles in the executive and legislative branches take effect.
Under the new framework, cabinet ministers who also serve as members of parliament must choose between their ministerial posts and their parliamentary seats. The provision marks a fundamental departure from the 2012 Provisional Constitution, which explicitly allowed members of parliament to serve in the Council of Ministers under Article 97.
According to ICRIC Chairman Burhan Adan Omar, the six-month transition period granted for the Constitution to take effect began on April 14, 2026, and ends on October 14, 2026. The notice states that a minister who is also a member of parliament will lose their Cabinet position if they choose to retain their parliamentary seat. Similarly, an MP will lose their parliamentary membership if they accept another government position.
The directive affects a significant portion of Prime Minister Hamza Abdi Barre’s cabinet. Official figures indicate that about 15 or 16 of the 25 ministers currently hold seats in either chamber of parliament, placing them directly in the scope of the order. Among those impacted is Deputy Prime Minister Salah Ahmed Jama, who serves in the Upper House.
Some ministers are reportedly reluctant to resign from parliament, fearing they may struggle to regain their seats in future political contests. A delegation led by the deputy prime minister recently approached President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud seeking a postponement of the implementation of the disputed provisions, allegedly. The delegation reportedly encountered resistance to delaying the requirement for officials to choose between parliamentary and ministerial roles.
The practical implications of the deadline remain unclear. Some observers believe the new restrictions may only practically apply after the next general election and the formation of a new government, rather than immediately affecting the current Cabinet. If implemented right away, the changes could trigger a major reshuffle in both government and Parliament.
The 2026 Constitutional Amendments
The constitutional amendments, signed into law by President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud on 8 March 2026, introduced sweeping changes to Somalia’s governance framework.
The amendments have been deeply contested. Puntland and Jubaland, two federal member states, have rejected the legitimacy of the amended constitution, arguing that the process lacked sufficient political consensus. Opposition figures, including former President Mohamed Abdullahi Farmaajo, have also criticized the amendments, warning that they could endanger national unity and deepen political divisions.
Opposition Challenges in Court
The opposition’s decision to challenge the constitution in court represents a shift in strategy. In recent months, opposition figures have pursued multiple avenues to resist the government’s agenda, including parliamentary motions, public protests and, in some cases, armed confrontation. As reported in FTL Somalia’s coverage of the Sharif standoff, former President Sharif Sheikh Ahmed has been under a security siege at his residence in Mogadishu, and the government has escalated its confrontation with opposition figures through the use of NISA forces and financial sanctions.
Against this backdrop, the decision to bring the constitutional dispute to the Supreme Court raises questions about whether the judiciary can serve as an independent arbiter. The Supreme Court’s composition and its relationship to the executive branch have been subjects of concern. As reported in FTL Somalia’s coverage of parliamentary dysfunction, Somalia’s institutions have struggled to function independently amid political pressure and institutional weaknesses.
The Supreme Court’s Recent Rulings
The Supreme Court has recently issued significant rulings on electoral matters. On 13 October 2026, it ratified the results of the Galmudug parliamentary rerun election, confirming the allocation of all 89 seats in the Galmudug House of Representatives. As reported in FTL Somalia’s coverage of the court’s August ruling, the same court had previously annulled the July 30 election results, demonstrating its willingness to intervene in electoral disputes.
However, the court’s independence in politically sensitive cases remains uncertain. The constitutional amendments fundamentally restructured the judiciary, including the Supreme Court itself, raising questions about whether the current court has the institutional independence to rule against the executive branch that appointed it.
Critical Note
The Supreme Court’s decision to hear opposition arguments on the new Constitution is significant, but it should be treated with caution. The fact that the court has agreed to hear the case does not mean it will rule against the government. In politically charged environments, courts can serve as legitimizing instruments for executive action, providing a veneer of legal approval for decisions that have already been made elsewhere.
The jurisdictional question is central to the legitimacy of the proceedings. Under both the 2012 Provisional Constitution and the 2026 Amendments, the Constitutional Court, not the Supreme Court, holds the mandate for constitutional interpretation. The Constitutional Court has never been established. The Supreme Court’s decision to accept the case may be an attempt to fill that void, but it also raises the possibility that the court is acting beyond its constitutional authority. If the Supreme Court issues a ruling on the constitution’s validity, that ruling could be challenged on the grounds that the court lacked jurisdiction to hear the case in the first place.
The October 14 deadline adds another layer of complexity. The forced separation of executive and legislative roles is a significant change that affects the composition of both the Cabinet and Parliament. If enforced immediately, it could trigger a major political reshuffle at a moment of already heightened tension. If delayed, it raises questions about whether the government is serious about implementing its own constitutional framework.
The lack of clarity about who filed the case and whether the opposition is united behind this strategy is itself telling. If the case was filed by a marginal opposition figure without broad support, it may have little impact. If it was orchestrated by Villa Somalia to create the appearance of judicial review while ensuring a favourable outcome, it could further undermine public trust in the judiciary.
Time will tell whether this is a genuine opportunity for the opposition to challenge the constitution through legal means or a calculated move to legitimize a document that key federal member states reject. The Supreme Court’s ruling, when it comes, will be scrutinized not only for its legal reasoning but for its political implications.
Share your story. FTL Somalia is continuing to investigate the constitutional dispute and the role of the judiciary in resolving political crises. If you have information or insights to share, contact us at info@ftlsomalia.com. Your identity will be protected.
Recommended Reading On ftlsomalia.com
- Somalia’s Constitutional Review Body Sets October 14 Deadline for Key Amendments
- ICRIC Confirms Somalia Has Taken a Major Step Toward Stronger Constitution
- President Sharif Documents Siege of His Home, Denies NISA Claims, Warns Against Justifying Opposition Bloodshed and Urges International Community to Act
- House of the People Misses Quorum for Second Time in a Week
- Supreme Court Overturns Galmudug Election Results




